Section 8 Company vs Society: Which is Better for Your NGO?

When starting a non-governmental organization (NGO) in India, one of the primary decisions you'll need to make is whether to register as a Section 8 Company or a Society. Both options serve charitable purposes but differ in their legal framework, benefits, and operational requirements. This article will help you understand the key differences to determine which structure suits your NGO better.

What is a Section 8 Company?

A Section 8 Company is a company registered under the Companies Act, 2013, with the aim of promoting charitable objectives such as social welfare, education, health, and more. Unlike traditional companies, Section 8 Companies do not distribute profits to their members but reinvest any surplus in furthering their objectives.

Key Features of a Section 8 Company:

1. Non-profit Distribution: No dividends are distributed to members.

2. Legal Status: It enjoys the legal status of a company, giving it greater credibility.

3. Tax Benefits: Section 8 Companies can avail tax exemptions under the Income Tax Act.

4. Compliance Requirements: They must comply with the same legal requirements as other companies, such as maintaining proper books of accounts and filing annual returns.

What is a Society?

A Society, on the other hand, is governed by the Societies Registration Act, 1860. Societies are formed for promoting activities such as literature, arts, and public welfare. Like a Section 8 Company, a Society is a non-profit organization, but its operational framework is distinct.

Key Features of a Society:

1. Governing Law: Societies are governed by state laws, which can vary across different states.

2. Flexible Structure: The formation process is less rigid compared to a Section 8 Company.

3. Membership: Societies require a minimum of seven members to start and can have more flexible membership rules.

4. Compliance: The compliance requirements for Societies are generally lower than those for Section 8 Companies, but they are not as legally recognized as companies.

Section 8 Company vs Society: Key Differences

1. Legal Recognition

Section 8 Company: More legally recognized, often preferred by government agencies, foreign donors, and corporate entities.
Society: Less recognized outside India and can face challenges in receiving foreign donations or partnerships.

2. Ease of Formation

Section 8 Company: Requires registration with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), making it a more stringent and time-consuming process.
Society: Registration is relatively simpler and governed by state-level authorities, offering flexibility in terms of procedures.

3. Compliance and Governance

Section 8 Company: High compliance requirements with strict governance structures, regular audits, and annual filings with the MCA.
Society: Fewer compliance obligations, though certain states may require regular filings and audits.

4. Tax Benefits

Section 8 Company: Eligible for tax exemptions under the Income Tax Act, and donors contributing to a Section 8 Company may receive tax deductions under Section 80G.
Society: Also eligible for tax exemptions, but the process is generally more cumbersome compared to a Section 8 Company.

5. Foreign Funding

Section 8 Company: Easier to get approval for foreign donations under the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA).
Society: Foreign funding is possible but may face additional scrutiny, especially in states where Societies are less regulated.

Which is Better for Your NGO: Section 8 Company or Society?

The choice between a Section 8 Company and a Society depends on your NGO's goals, scale, and operational needs.

• Choose a Section 8 Company if you are looking for a more formal structure, better legal recognition, and the ability to raise foreign funds. It is an ideal choice if your NGO will operate at a national or international level and will require significant donations or grants.

• Choose a Society if your NGO will function primarily at a state or local level and you prefer flexibility in operations and lower compliance costs. Societies are best suited for smaller organizations or community-based initiatives that don’t require foreign funding.

Conclusion

Both Section 8 Companies and Societies serve the charitable sector in India, but their frameworks and benefits cater to different needs. If you're aiming for greater recognition, robust governance, and access to foreign funds, a Section 8 Company Registration might be the way forward. However, if flexibility and ease of formation are your priority, a Society may be a more suitable option.

Must Read: How Online Business Registration Can Streamline Your Startup Process